Catholic School Deletes Student's Coming Out Story
This article presents the following Legal Issues:
Censorship- The private school the journalist attended censored his editorial and silenced his opinion by taking the post of of the school newspaper's website.
Fair Comment or Criticism- The journalist had the right to comment on the DVD sent out by the Archbishop who endorsed the policy of anti-gay marriage laws in the state; same-sex marriage is certainly an issue of public interest.
Opinion Privilege- The journalist also had the right to speak openly about his stance on same-sex marriage and the controversial DVD endorsing anti-gay marriage laws. He also had the right to give encouragement to those in similar situations as him and for everybody to fight for equality and to stop injustice.
Summary:
After an anti-gay gay marriage video was distributed to students and families of the Benilde-St. Margeret's School, a private Catholic preparatory school in Minnesota, Sean Simonson, a school staff writer, published an editorial on the school newspaper's website.
In the editorial, Simonson speaks out against the video, saying it was "inappropriate due to the civil nature of the video, and the content is nothing more than simple, emotional propaganda."
Simonson states that the Church has every right to deny same-sex marriage within the Church, but as a legal and civil issue, the Church has no right to deny same-sex marriage.
Shortly after the editorial was published online, the school administrators took down the article, saying the article created a "disrespectful environment" and caused "confusion about the teachings of the Catholic Church."
Simonson also published an editorial about his own coming-out story, stating that he has contemplated suicide and speaks about the everyday horrors he had to experience. SPLC executive director Frank LaMonte says the private school has every right to take down the article, but handling the situation in a different way would have been much better. It is clear the student had been bullied in the past for his sexuality; now, it appears, that he is being bullied a second time by the school administration by deleting his article from the website.
Simonson's editorial was posted on a local news website and he the newspaper staff is currently trying to get the original editorial back up on the website, without the comments.
Next time include your reaction to the event.
ReplyDelete