Friday, January 28, 2011

Reaction to AAR Jan. 28


Summary:

My "adopted reporter" is Dave Philipps of the Colorado Gazette.  Philipps was honored as a Pulitzer Prize finalist for his article on returning veterans from the wars in the Middle East, "Casualties of War."  In this article, Philipps reports on the violence in the Colorado Springs area conducted by veterans from the War in Iraq; these veterans were stationed at Fort Carson, a military base near Colorado Srprings.

Because of the traumatic and violent encounters the soldiers encountered in Iraq, most soldiers out of the 4th Division's 4th Combat Brigade from Fort Carson suffered from post-traumatic stress disorder, or PTSD.  When they returned to Fort Carson, the killing continued from the battlefield onto the streets of Colorado Springs.

From the infantry unit, ten members have been arrested and accused of murder or attempted murder.  Others have committed suicide or attempted it.  A vicious cycle of drug abuse, domestic violence, pain, confusion, counselling, murders, and violence on the streets have riddled the unit.  They state that no one tought them how to stop their jobs once they returned to the U.S., so it wasn't as easy as flipping a switch off to stop hurting others.  Most also lied about suffering from PTSD to get out of the military base faster and back to their home lives.

Philipps continues to report about situations of drug abuse and how the soldiers cope with the change in atmosphere from the battlefield to back home.  Some seeked counselling sessions and reported how they felt to military commanders and specialists, and others kept it a secret.  Throughout the stroy, Philipps tells about other situations soldiers had gotten into and the current situations of the soldiers; whether they were doing time in jail or in therapy or trying to live their lives "normally."

Reaction:

From the very beginning, this article caught my attention; just the topic itself was something that is seldom covered. Many times, "war stories" take place on the battlefield; on the front lines.  However, this story took place on a different front: the home front. 

I found this article extremely eye-opening and it gave me a different perspective on the war situation, just like a good article should.  When soldiers return home, most people assume everything is fine and that the soliders are just happy to see their families.  However, this article shed light on what was really the case: most soldiers do suffer from some form of PTSD after returning home from battle.  Whethe the transition is easy or hard, soldiers do experience a massive transformation in atmosphere.  Philipps did an incredible job of reporting multiple situations and facts about these soldiers' home lives and current situations.  Through his reporting, the reader was given a different perspective on soldiers and probably learned about an entirely new subject to them. 

This article makes it obvious as to why Philipps was Pulitzer Prize finalist: inside reporting that sheds light on a brand new topic and gives a unique and bold perspective on American soldiers is bound to gain some attention.  This article was eye-opening, and overall, incredibly interesting and well-written. 

Friday, January 21, 2011

FS Free Press Issue #6 Critique

1. Praise- The article discussing the new class structure was insightful and well-written.  The authors made sure to cover all of the noteworthy issues like class scheduling, freshman arrival, and how these changes will affect students.  Students' opinions--from juniors to eighth graders-- were given as well, which gives a consensus from different groups on what next year will be like.  The structure of the article was also set up nicely; information about freshmen, staff, and opinions were easy to find.  Overall, this was a very interesting and helpful article that helped shed some light on an issue that will affect all of us in the school next year and for years to come.

2. Praise- The article about Philosophy Club interested me because I am a member.  It gave a solid overview about what the club was about and its weekly procedures.  The author explained certain activities that take place in the club-- such as watching movies and following up with a discussion-- as well as having a civil debate about thought-provoking topics.  However, I thought the author repeated himself a few times and could have gone into more detail about certain topics the club has discussed.  Overall, this was a very interesting article and I'm glad more attention is being paid to a fun, thought-provoking, and interesting school club.

3. Constructive Criticism- Overall, issue #6 of the Free Press was interesting and well-put-together.  However, there are a few exceptions.  I thought the layout for the tattoo article was a little overwhelming at first; instead of catchy to the reader's eye.  The font was relatively small and the diagram of the human body created a lot of white space that couldn't be used.  It also seems like a lot of information was crammed into a small space; if five students are going to be interviewed, each with comments regarding tattoos, more space should be given so the reader does not feel overwhelmed.  However, the article was interesting to read and presented a new topic that usually isn't in the school newspaper.

4. Constructive Criticism- Although I found the Philosophy Club article informative and interesting, the author repeated certain facts about Philosophy Club; including information about weekly procedures and activities such as watching and discussing movies.  The author could have elborated more on topics the club discusses and students' favorite topics.  Also an opinion section from club members-- not senior members-- could have been added to give more perspective on how the club works.

5. Constructive Criticism- The title "Undercover Parents" didn't relate to the article topic that well.  Looking at the title, I was expecting to read something about parents with top secret jobs.  Although the article consisted of interesting information, it could have been written better.  The transitions from one student's parents to another were confusing; the topic would focus on a certain student's parents and then switch over to another student's parents pretty quickly.  This made it hard to know why information was given about that student's parents in the first place.  The first part of the article talked about a student's dad meeting Khloe Kardashian, while it is impressive, it had little to do with the rest of the article's issue about parents and their relationships with their kids.

Wednesday, January 19, 2011

SPLC NewsFlash Reaction #1

Catholic School Deletes Student's Coming Out Story

This article presents the following Legal Issues:

Censorship- The private school the journalist attended censored his editorial and silenced his opinion by taking the post of of the school newspaper's website.

Fair Comment or Criticism- The journalist had the right to comment on the DVD sent out by the Archbishop who endorsed the policy of anti-gay marriage laws in the state; same-sex marriage is certainly an issue of public interest.

Opinion Privilege- The journalist also had the right to speak openly about his stance on same-sex marriage and the controversial DVD endorsing anti-gay marriage laws.  He also had the right to give encouragement to those in similar situations as him and for everybody to fight for equality and to stop injustice.

Summary:

After an anti-gay gay marriage video was distributed to students and families of the Benilde-St. Margeret's School, a private Catholic preparatory school in Minnesota, Sean Simonson, a school staff writer, published an editorial on the school newspaper's website. 

In the editorial, Simonson speaks out against the video, saying it was "inappropriate due to the civil nature of the video, and the content is nothing more than simple, emotional propaganda."

Simonson states that the Church has every right to deny same-sex marriage within the Church, but as a legal and civil issue, the Church has no right to deny same-sex marriage.

Shortly after the editorial was published online, the school administrators took down the article, saying the article created a "disrespectful environment" and caused "confusion about the teachings of the Catholic Church."

Simonson also published an editorial about his own coming-out story, stating that he has contemplated suicide and speaks about the everyday horrors he had to experience.  SPLC executive director Frank LaMonte says the private school has every right to take down the article, but handling the situation in a different way would have been much better.  It is clear the student had been bullied in the past for his sexuality; now, it appears, that he is being bullied a second time by the school administration by deleting his article from the website.

Simonson's editorial was posted on a local news website and he the newspaper staff is currently trying to get the original editorial back up on the website, without the comments.

Friday, January 14, 2011

Current Events 1/14/11

Michael Steele Faces Tough Re-Election Battle

This current event includes the following elements of newsworthiness:

Timeliness- with the RNC looking for a candidate to run in the 2012 election, Steele's outcome for the fight for the GOP chairman position may decide his future political career

Impact- during Steele's term as the GOP chairman, fundraising troubles and minor financial scandals occurred; who takes the GOP chairman position may either continue fundraising troubles or reverse them.  Whoever is elected chairman will have a major impact on the standing of the GOP party.

Prominence- in a political atmosphere based on competition, Steele's fight for the GOP chairman position is much like many other races for public office spots seen a lot in today's political scene

Summary:
By next Friday, the GOP will know who its chairman is.  While encumbent Michael Steele fights for the position, he faces opposition from four other candidates, all promising to fix the mistakes that Steele made during his two years as GOP chairman; especially concerning funding.  Despite his last-chance campaigning efforts, many analysts speculate that Steele will not retake his position; mainly due to the amount of controversy and poor financial skills Steele showed.  Steele created a $15 million dollar debt during his two-year term.

Junior Highs May Make Transformations into Middle Schools with New Names

This current event shows the following elements of newsworthiness:

Proximity- because most residents in Lawrence have kids go through the public schooling system and this decision directly effects those we know in the public schooling system

Prominence- for about the past year, the Lawrence School Board has been strategizing and working to change the structure of our current schooling system.  This current event is just another part of making the transformation

Audience- many parents in Lawrence have or had kids go through the Lawrence public schooling system; the audience is the entirety of the students and parents affected by the school board's decisions.

Summary:

With its transformation into a new schooling structre-- junior highs being converted into 6-8 grade middle schools and high schools now including freshmen-- schools are being considered to be renamed by the school board.  However, the school board encourages members of the schools' faculties and of the community to have a say in the renaming of the schools. 

Community members can send in opinions about the new names of the schools by contacting any of the four school board members who voted on this policy, or by contacting First Bell or mfagan@ljworld.com

Republicans of the House Will Start on Consideration to Repeal Health Care Bill Next Week

This current event shows the following elements of newsworthiness:

Prominence- Health care is a major issue in the US right now; the Republicans' new majority in the House also begs the question on what they will do regarding the new health care policy.

Timeliness- The shootings in Tuscon on Sunday marked a sad and confusing time for America, as Congress pulled their agenda this week to think about the Tuscon shootings.

Impact- After President Obama called for a more civil tone to political discourse, analysts will be watching the atmosphere in the House to see if Congress members are restraining from harsher political attitudes.

Summary:

After the Tuscon shootings on Sunday, Congress will cautiously resume their meetings next week.  For Republicans in the House, this means they will resume their efforts to repeal the health care bill passed last year. 

The Tuscon shootings left many to question if the harsh and blame-ridden political atmosphere spurred on by news stations and political office holders was the cause for such a violent attack.  Analysts watching the House next week will see if Congress members restrain from a harsher political tone and if they respond to President Obama's suggestions to have a more civil-toned political atmosphere.

500 Dead, Thousands Injured in Flood in Brazil

This current event shows these elements of newsworthiness:

Impact: the rains causing the floods stunned Brazil's mountainess terrain; a popular tourist destination that is now in havoc

Drama: the fact that rains can flood mountainside villages and towns is quite incredible and scary

Summary:

Since the beginning of the year, rains have showered Brazil and caused many villages to become flooded.  In the Brazilian state of Rio de Janeiro, over 500 civilians died and over 10,000 civilians were injured due to the flood. 

Officials say that they fear more civilians are harmed or even dead, and rescue efforts have been delayed due to constant rain in the area.  Downpours are supposed to continue for several more days, slowing rescue and relief efforts.  Many criticize Brazilian authorites for the lack of disaster-safe infrastructure and the fact that they still allow citizens to build in disaster-prone areas. 

Families are still living in house on mountainsides, valleys, and riversides that have not been destroyed by the flood yet.  Rescue workers and authorities are evacuating over 5000 families that live in the area.

Wednesday, January 5, 2011

Five Freedoms

The five freedoms the First Amendment gives are:
1.Speech
2.Religion
3.Press
4.Assembly
5.Petition

Although all the freedoms protected by the First Amendment are valuable to us as United States citizens, the freedom of speech allows Americans to strive for individuality and form of opinions without being oppresed.  The freedom of speech also grants Americans the right to protest peacefully, uniting individuals into groups who share their beliefs.  Without the freedom of speech, the United States would not retain one of the most important qualities that it holds: expression.

Colonists fled from Great Britain because they were persecuted by oppresive rule that did not allow them to practice these basic rights granted by the First Amendment.  Because of Britain's oppresive rule, these five freedoms were grouped together in the First Amendment of the Bill of Rights because these rights are what the Founding Fathers sought as most important.