Friday, January 21, 2011

FS Free Press Issue #6 Critique

1. Praise- The article discussing the new class structure was insightful and well-written.  The authors made sure to cover all of the noteworthy issues like class scheduling, freshman arrival, and how these changes will affect students.  Students' opinions--from juniors to eighth graders-- were given as well, which gives a consensus from different groups on what next year will be like.  The structure of the article was also set up nicely; information about freshmen, staff, and opinions were easy to find.  Overall, this was a very interesting and helpful article that helped shed some light on an issue that will affect all of us in the school next year and for years to come.

2. Praise- The article about Philosophy Club interested me because I am a member.  It gave a solid overview about what the club was about and its weekly procedures.  The author explained certain activities that take place in the club-- such as watching movies and following up with a discussion-- as well as having a civil debate about thought-provoking topics.  However, I thought the author repeated himself a few times and could have gone into more detail about certain topics the club has discussed.  Overall, this was a very interesting article and I'm glad more attention is being paid to a fun, thought-provoking, and interesting school club.

3. Constructive Criticism- Overall, issue #6 of the Free Press was interesting and well-put-together.  However, there are a few exceptions.  I thought the layout for the tattoo article was a little overwhelming at first; instead of catchy to the reader's eye.  The font was relatively small and the diagram of the human body created a lot of white space that couldn't be used.  It also seems like a lot of information was crammed into a small space; if five students are going to be interviewed, each with comments regarding tattoos, more space should be given so the reader does not feel overwhelmed.  However, the article was interesting to read and presented a new topic that usually isn't in the school newspaper.

4. Constructive Criticism- Although I found the Philosophy Club article informative and interesting, the author repeated certain facts about Philosophy Club; including information about weekly procedures and activities such as watching and discussing movies.  The author could have elborated more on topics the club discusses and students' favorite topics.  Also an opinion section from club members-- not senior members-- could have been added to give more perspective on how the club works.

5. Constructive Criticism- The title "Undercover Parents" didn't relate to the article topic that well.  Looking at the title, I was expecting to read something about parents with top secret jobs.  Although the article consisted of interesting information, it could have been written better.  The transitions from one student's parents to another were confusing; the topic would focus on a certain student's parents and then switch over to another student's parents pretty quickly.  This made it hard to know why information was given about that student's parents in the first place.  The first part of the article talked about a student's dad meeting Khloe Kardashian, while it is impressive, it had little to do with the rest of the article's issue about parents and their relationships with their kids.

5 comments:

  1. Extra credit: How many stories do should a reader find personally relevant in each issue?

    ReplyDelete
  2. Not every newspaper is going to satisfy every reader with every story. I think a newspaper should shoot for 2-3 stories that the reader finds interesting and relevant. The wider the variety the stories, the better chance that the reader will find it interesting.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Newspapers should have at least 3-4 stories that a person could relate to. The cover story of a newspaper should always catch the readers attention and therefore be interesting to most readers.

    ReplyDelete
  4. I think that there should be at least 3 articles that someone could relate to/be interested in. Not everything in the paper is going to satisfy everyone, but I think the broadest story would be the cover because that's what gets people's attention and makes them want to open the paper to find out more.

    ReplyDelete
  5. Not everyone is easy to please when it comes to what news to print and what news to not print. So although there should be atleast 3 articles that entertain a reader, it's doubtful that happens to every reader. One would think that the most interesting stories should be near the front, but with newspapers entertaining such a wide range of people the best thing to do is print information that a majority of the readers will like. It's necessary to think about every reader when constructing a newspaper.

    ReplyDelete